•  
  •  
 

Abstract

With the current criminal compliance pilot, how to apply it correctly in the field of food safety is a new research direction. Starting from the criminal behavior of substantive law, this paper probes into the rationality of applying compliance non-prosecution in food production and operation enterprises, and through the analysis of the application of criminal compliance non-prosecution, puts forward the measures for applying the system in the field of food safety.

Publication Date

10-30-2023

First Page

65

Last Page

70

DOI

10.13652/j.spjx.1003.5788.2023.80282

References

[1] 郑学林, 刘敏, 高燕竹, 等. 食品安全司法解释（一）的理解与适用[J]. 人民司法, 2021（13）: 31-38. ZHENG X L, LIU M, GAO Y Z, et al. Understanding and application of interpretation of food safety law[J]. People's Judicial, 2021（13）: 31-38.
[2] REILLY P. Corporate deferred prosecution as discretionary injustice[J]. Utah Law Review, 2017, 2 017（5）: 839-883.
[3] 黎宏. 合规计划与企业刑事责任[J]. 法学杂志, 2019, 40（9）: 9-19. LI H. Compliance planning and corporate criminal responsibility[J]. Journal of Law, 2019, 40（9）: 9-19.
[4] 陈瑞华. 企业合规不起诉制度研究[J]. 中国刑事法杂志, 2021（1）: 78-96. CHEN R H. The research on the non-prosecution system of enterprise compliance[J]. Chinese Journal of Criminal Law, 2021（1）: 78-96.
[5] 赵炜佳. 论刑事合规的发展沿革法理基础与本土内化[J]. 中国刑警学院学报, 2019（5）: 64-69. ZHAO W J. On the development and evolution of criminal compliance jurisprudence and local internalization[J]. Journal of Chinese Interpol College, 2019（5）: 64-69.
[6] 唐政委, 杨畅. 企业合规不起诉: 刑事司法的新面向领域[J]. 现代企业, 2023（1）: 140-142. TANG Z W, YANG C. Corporate compliance non-prosecution: A new orientation for criminal justice[J]. Modern Enterprise, 2023（1）: 140-142.
[7] 刘少军. 企业合规不起诉制度本土化的可能及限度[J]. 法学杂志, 2021, 42（1）: 51-65. LIU S J. The possibility and limit of localization of corporate compliance non-prosecution system[J]. Journal of Law, 2021, 42（1）: 51-65.
[8] 周晗燕. 《食品安全法》第136条“尽职免责”条款的适用探析[J]. 天津大学学报（社会科学版）, 2021, 23（4）: 340-346. ZHOU H Y. Analysis on the application of article 136 "duty exemption" in food safety law[J]. Journal of Tianjin University （Society Science Edition）, 2021, 23（4）: 340-346.
[9] 陈瑞华. 企业合规不起诉改革的八大争议问题[J]. 中国法律评论, 2021（4）: 1-29. CHEN R H. Eight controversial issues in the reform of corporate compliance non-prosecution[J]. China Law Review, 2021（4）: 1-29.
[10] 杨宇冠, 李涵笑. 企业合规不起诉监管问题比较研究[J]. 浙江工商大学学报, 2021（4）: 46-58. YANG Y G, LI H X. A comparative study on the regulation of non-prosecution in enterprises[J]. Journal of Zhejiang Gongshang University, 2021（4）: 46-58.
[11] 严忠华, 蔡红伟, 赵雅蒙. 企业犯罪相对不起诉制度引入合规监督考察的实践与思考[J]. 犯罪研究, 2021（5）: 18-27. YAN Z H, CAI H W, ZHAO Y M. Practice and reflection on the introduction of the relative non-prosecution system of enterprise crime compliance supervision and inspection[J]. Criminal Research, 2021（5）: 18-27.
[12] 赵赤. 企业刑事合规视野下的单位犯罪构造及出罪路径[J]. 政法论坛, 2022, 40（5）: 103-115. ZHAO C. The structure of single crime and the path of exoneration from the perspective of corporate criminal compliance[J]. Forum of Politics and Law, 2022, 40（5）: 103-115.
[13] 黎宏. 企业合规不起诉: 误解及纠正[J]. 中国法律评论, 2021（3）: 177-188. LI H. Corporate compliance non-prosecution: Misunderstanding and correction[J]. China Law Review, 2021（3）: 177-188.
[14] 曾娜, 张立基. 食品安全行政处罚双罚制的适用研究[N]. 中国市场监管报, 2021-12-07（3）. ZENG N, ZHANG L J. Study on the application of double penalty system in food safety administration[N]. China Market Supervision News, 2021-12-07（3）.
[15] 刘艳红. 刑事实体法的合规激励立法研究[J]. 法学, 2023（1）: 79-94. LIU Y H. A study on the legislation of compliance incentive in criminal substantial law[J]. Jurisprudence, 2023（1）: 79-94.
[16] 时延安, 陈振炜. 检察机关主导型合规模式中的监督与合作[J]. 法治研究, 2023（2）: 137-147. SHI Y A, CHEN Z W. Supervision and cooperation in the compliance model dominated by procuratorial organs[J]. Law Research, 2023（2）: 137-147.
[17] 姜先良. 中国特色现代企业规制司法制度探析: 以涉案企业合规不起诉制度完善为分析视角[J]. 人民检察, 2021（9）: 17-19. JIANG X L. Analysis on the judicial system of modern enterprise regulation with chinese characteristics: From the perspective of the improvement of the non-prosecution system for enterprises involved in cases[J]. People's Procuratorate, 2021（9）: 17-19.
[18] 张迪. 刑事合规视野下企业缓起诉制度功能定位的反思与借鉴[J]. 财经法学, 2021（5）: 125-138. ZHANG D. Reflection and reference on the functional orientation of enterprise deferred prosecution system from the perspective of criminal compliance[J]. Financial and Economic Law, 2021（5）: 125-138.
[19] 万方. 美国刑法中的合规计划及其启示[J]. 人民检察, 2018（11）: 72-75. WAN F. Compliance program in American criminal law and its implications[J]. People's Procuratorate, 2018（11）: 72-75.
[20] 徐鹏博, 黎宏. 美国法人犯罪刑事责任的认定及其启示[J]. 人民检察, 2017（19）: 71-75. XU B P, LI H. The determination of the criminal responsibility of legal persons in the united states and its inspiration[J]. People's Procuratorate, 2017（19）: 71-75.
[21] 周恒. 食品安全“构罪免刑”情形行政处罚法律适用问题探析[J]. 中国市场监管研究, 2022（5）: 64-68. ZHOU H. Analysis on the law application of administrative punishment in the case of "exemption from punishment for constitution crime" in food safety[J]. China Market Regulation Research, 2022（5）: 64-68.
[22] 程民科. 经济法视域下食品安全监管的规范化发展: 评《食品安全监管与合规: 理论、规范与案例》[J]. 食品安全质量检测学报, 2022, 13（21）: 7 127. CHENG M K. Standardization development of food safety supervision from the perspective of economic law: Review on food safety supervisionand compliance: Theory, norms and cases[J]. Journal of Food Safety Quality Testing, 2022, 13（21）: 7 127.
[23] 杜闯. 政府监管与食品质量安全[J]. 食品安全导刊, 2022（28）: 32-34. DU C. Government regulation and food quality and safety[J]. Food Safety Guide, 2022（28）: 32-34.
[24] 时延安, 孟珊. 规制、合规与刑事制裁: 以食品安全为论域[J]. 山东社会科学, 2020（5）: 45-50. SHI Y A, MENG S. Regulation, compliance and criminal sanctions: Taking food safety as the domain of discourse[J]. Shandong Society Science, 2020（5）: 45-50.
[25] 黄现清, 张斌峰. “互联网+”背景下网络食品安全犯罪的刑法规范反思与理论适用[J]. 天津师范大学学报（社会科学版）, 2022（6）: 87-92. HUANG X Q, ZHANG B F. The reflection and theoretical application of the criminal law norm of online food safety crime in the context of "internetworking +"[J]. Journal of Tianjin Shifan University （Society Science Edition）, 2022（6）: 87-92.
[26] 计金娣, 万其明, 邢雅丽. 检察机关涉案企业刑事合规问题研究[J/OL]. 北京警察学院学报. （2023-01-17） [2023-03-16]. https://doi.org/10.16478/j.cnki.jbjpc.20230106.002. JI J D, WAN Q M, XING Y L. Research on criminal compliance of procuratorial organ involved in enterprises[J/OL]. Journal of Beijing Police College. （2023-01-17） [2023-03-16]. https://doi.org/10.16478/j.cnki.jbjpc.20230106.002.
[27] 宗帅斌. 刑事合规制度的三种模式及其本土构建[J]. 平顶山学院学报, 2022,37（6）: 23-27. ZONG S B. Three models of criminal compliance system and local construction[J]. Journal of Pingdingshan College, 2022, 37（6）: 23-27.
[28] 刘俊海. 合伙企业不是单位犯罪主体的法律逻辑[J]. 法律适用, 2019（23）: 40-47. LIU J H. Legal logic that joint enterprise is not the subject of single crime[J]. Applicable Law, 2019（23）: 40-47.
[29] 苏晓阳, 许明. 企业合规的行刑衔接研究[J]. 山东法官培训学院学报, 2022, 38（6）: 151-164. SU X Y, XU M. A study on the convergence of execution and punishment in enterprise compliance[J]. Journal of Shandong Judge Training Institute, 2022, 38（6）: 151-164.
[30] 郭华. 企业合规整改行刑衔接的协调机制[J]. 华东政法大学学报, 2022, 25（6）: 38-49. GUO H. Coordination mechanism of enterprises' compliance rectification and execution convergence[J]. Journal of East China University of Political Science and Law, 2022, 25（6）: 38-49.
[31] 单森林. 合规检察制度中实施少捕慎诉慎押刑事司法政策研究[J]. 湖湘论坛, 2022, 35（6）: 51-63. SHAN S L. Study on criminal justice policy of less arrest and cautious prosecution in compliance procuratorial system[J]. Huxiang Forum, 2022, 35（6）: 51-63.
[32] 王晨旭, 王力. 企业刑事责任视野下探究刑事合规的适用范围[J]. 河北企业, 2022（10）: 136-139. WANG C X, WANG L. Exploring the applicable scope of criminal compliance in the view of corporate responsibility[J]. Hebei Enterprise, 2022（10）: 136-139.
[33] 史蔚. 企业合规人员不作为刑事责任探析[J]. 法学家, 2022（5）: 87-101, 193-194. SHI W. Analysis on the criminal responsibility of compliance personnel in enterprises[J]. Jurist, 2022（5）: 87-101, 193-194.
[34] 李玉华. 企业合规与刑事诉讼立法[J]. 政法论坛, 2022, 40（5）: 91-102. LI Y H. Corporate compliance and criminal lawsuit legislation[J]. Forum on Politics and Law, 2022, 40（5）: 91-102.
[35] 刘少军. 企业合规不起诉制度本土化的可能及限度[J]. 法学杂志, 2021, 42（1）: 51-65. LIU S J. The possibility and limit of localization of corporate compliance non-prosecution system[J]. Journal of Law, 2021, 42（1）: 51-65.
[34] 刘宁, 刘海廷. 企业刑事合规的三种模式[J]. 中外企业文化, 2023（1）: 76-78. LIU N. Three models of corporate criminal compliance[J]. Sino-Foreign Culture, 2023（1）: 76-78.
[37] 李玉华. 以合规为核心的企业认罪认罚从宽制度[J]. 浙江工商大学学报, 2021（1）: 61-71. LI Y H. Compliance as the core of the enterprise confession and punishment leniency system[J]. Journal of Zhejiang University of Industry and Commerce, 2021（1）: 61-71.
[38] 彭欣悦. 刑事合规背景下单位责任人的出罪逻辑与路径[J/OL]. 北京警察学院学报. （2023-03-14） [2023-03-16].DOI:10.16478/j.cnki.jbjpc.20230313.002. PENG X Y. The logic and path of unit responsible person's exoneration in the background of criminal compliance[J/OL]. Journal of Beijing Police College. （2023-03-14） [2023-03-16]. DOI:10.16478/j.cnki.jbjpc.20230313.002.
[39] 刘静静. 刑事合规视域下企业出罪化的实践考察及规范进路: 以“法益可恢复性”为视角[J]. 山东法官培训学院学报, 2023, 39（1）: 40-60. LIU J J. A practical investigation and normative approach of enterprise criminalization in the perspective of criminal compliance: From the perspective of "recoverability of legal benefits"[J]. Journal of Shandong Judge Training College, 2023, 39（1）: 40-60.
[40] 董文蕙, 尹锐平. 涉单位犯罪的刑事归责与合规适用[J]. 苏州大学学报（法学版）, 2023, 10（1）: 122-133. DONG W H, YIN R P. Criminal imputation and compliance application of individual crime[J]. Journal of Soochow University（Law Edition）, 2023, 10（1）: 122-133.

Download

Share

COinS
 
 

To view the content in your browser, please download Adobe Reader or, alternately,
you may Download the file to your hard drive.

NOTE: The latest versions of Adobe Reader do not support viewing PDF files within Firefox on Mac OS and if you are using a modern (Intel) Mac, there is no official plugin for viewing PDF files within the browser window.